behindthetimes
Recommended Character
💭thinking back...
Posts: 44
Pronouns: she/her
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"https://i.imgur.com/eb85dDP.png","color":"#FBB7A4"}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 501C10
Mini-Profile Text Color: 501C10
|
Post by behindthetimes on May 17, 2024 0:57:21 GMT
DEATH! BETRAYAL! COINY! What did YOU think of BFDIA 12?!
|
|
|
Post by tangerines on May 17, 2024 2:14:57 GMT
holy shit they finally canonized rubys sisters
|
|
|
Post by tangerines on May 17, 2024 2:31:24 GMT
this was an awesome episode, distinctly a bit less funny i think than the most recent few eps (at least to my tastes of humor) but what it was missing in funny moments it more than makes up for in like. weird ass 4th wall breaking i could only expect from the huangs... loved seeing more of the world of goiky outside of how it exists in the show itself AND YEAH I LOVED RUBYS SISTERS THEYRE FUN... AND THE KEVIN MACLEOD APPEARANCE OMG <333
|
|
viscera zombie
Contestant
its all about the he-said, she-said bullshit >_>...
Posts: 230
Pronouns: it/its
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"","color":""}
|
Post by viscera zombie on May 17, 2024 2:43:46 GMT
sighhh. i dont wanna be too harsh but i gotta give my criticism here. though its mostly just personal opinion, i dont know if i would consider any of my criticisms to be objective flaws. i haven't really enjoyed any of the recent BFDIA episodes at all! there were a few good things about this one and previous ones but i haven't found any of the newer episodes all that funny or interesting at all. ive been enjoying all the celebrity voice cameos and was especially shocked by the man himself Kevin MacLeod voicing a character this episode, a couple of the jokes made me chuckle, but man... im just bored overall with the newer episodes. i could cite a few reasons why:
1. too many of the jokes just feel like a character says something rAnDoM and another character yells about how awesome it is. its the sorta random = funny that doesnt commit enough to the randomness but doesnt fall back on being clever so its not really random OR funny. its just childish, in a bad way. feels like things just happen and theres no direction. the callbacks they do feel super forced rather than funny and i can say the same for their attempts at connecting the season to BFB (which, hey, i can appreciate trying to add some continuity, but i feels like it ruins some of BFB's jokes. IDFB when it eventually comes back should be the point that connects the seasons together, in all honesty, not the middle of BFDIA, and i certainly dont think we needed an entire backstory for Purpleface because it sorta ruins his introduction in BFB.) also, maybe its just my sensory issues, but does anyone else feel like the characters have been very... loud? like theyre yelling all their jokes to make them funnier? 2. it feels rushed. has anyone else noticed just how quickly BFDIA episodes are coming out? i think a new episode has come out every month or so, looking at JNJ's videos, meanwhile TPOT episodes come out around 2 months from each other. i know the animation probably doesnt take as much time as TPOT's but i cant help but feel like the frequency of new episode releases is REALLY felt in the writing. best way i can describe the dialogue is just awkward. its like a first draft, almost. and hey, im no stranger to going with my first draft, my middle school english teachers can confirm, but i definitely think some of the episode ideas and scripts should have had a little more time in the oven. yeah, im also not a fan of some of the actual episode plots. they dont really feel all that creative or interesting. like, in the previous episode, stealing Flower's petals is NOT an interesting challenge im sorry. we should have gotten that beauty contest. and this episode, i mean... bug dodgeball is kinda cool i guess but i was barely paying attention bc i just felt kinda bored. i dont like how the executed it. im biased but nothing is gonna top TPOT's zombie apocalypse challenge to me sorry 3. i dont want to accuse JNJ of being lazy, because i know theyre not. regardless of the quality, art takes time, and especially so for an entire full-length animated TV show episode. i have very negative opinions on BFDIA at the moment but i can still acknowledge that this stuff takes a shit load of effort. i think its moreso a drawback of trying to focus on two seasons at once. when youre trying to get a ~20 minute episode out every month while also trying to focus on a ~30 episode at the same time, i think its inevitable that the quality is gonna suffer a bit. might be an unpopular opinion but i think they should have waited to bring back BFDIA so they could put their full focus on it. yes that would mean it would take EVEN LONGER for the return of something the OSC has been waiting for for years, but the return so far is kinda disappointing. again, this is all just my own opinion. i dont wanna objectively say BFDIA is bad or anything. i just feel so bored watching it that it cant keep my attention and i just stare at the screen until its over LMAO. i already forgot basically everything in this episode so this turned into a rant about BFDIA as a whole rather than a proper review of This Episode Specifically...
|
|
|
Post by nikshalark on May 17, 2024 21:48:09 GMT
i think bfdia 12 was pretty good it had coiny in it which is always nice. i think its a fucking copout the way pin's lack of face and limbs is treated. she should just be a brain in a jar unable to do anything except think with no way to communicate with the outside world and it should be as torturous as every hell created by god and man. flower was also very cute this episode im glad shes back
also what the fuck happened to the thread
|
|
viscera zombie
Contestant
its all about the he-said, she-said bullshit >_>...
Posts: 230
Pronouns: it/its
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"","color":""}
|
Post by viscera zombie on May 17, 2024 21:52:45 GMT
i think bfdia 12 was pretty good it had coiny in it which is always nice. i think its a fucking copout the way pin's lack of face and limbs is treated. she should just be a brain in a jar unable to do anything except think with no way to communicate with the outside world and it should be as torturous as every hell created by god and man. flower was also very cute this episode im glad shes back also what the fuck happened to the thread an admin merged the two threads together since they're about the exact same topic. it seems that in doing so the main thread (behindthetimes' thread) got put UNDER mintykiwi's lievblogging thread. apologies for the confusion!
|
|
|
Post by tangerines on May 17, 2024 21:56:06 GMT
ya my idea was to have new pinned threads where all discussion for each episode of a show could go when each one comes out! it doesnt really matter who the op is, i just want users to have a place to read all the discussion/takes on an episode in one place ^w^
|
|
behindthetimes
Recommended Character
💭thinking back...
Posts: 44
Pronouns: she/her
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"https://i.imgur.com/eb85dDP.png","color":"#FBB7A4"}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 501C10
Mini-Profile Text Color: 501C10
|
Post by behindthetimes on May 17, 2024 22:07:19 GMT
i say this as somebody who likes bfdia and basically always enjoys watching it: if anything i wish they'd focus more on refining a shorter script. cary has like infinite resources now so he can just make 30 minute episodes every month and its seriously hurting the pacing and general quality of bfdi. just make ten minute episodes with less padding and more focus on actual jokes. the last two episodes of bfdia have been way better because they've got a co-writer who's probably reigning cary in a bit. i hope it gets better from here. i dont like that they're gonna return to the crap 3d world
|
|
natus
Debuter
mlp squee
Posts: 155
Pronouns: he/xe/it
Mini-Profile Background: {"image":"https://i.ibb.co/qgXz905/muuuh.png","color":"#2B244D"}
Mini-Profile Name Color: 44EE8C
Mini-Profile Text Color: 660C0E
|
Post by natus on May 23, 2024 23:34:02 GMT
BFDIA 12 was AWESOME it has to be one of my fav modern BFDIA eps so far!! full of lots of funny bits one of the ones i think about a lot is the rice bit, ITS LIKE. WHEN THERES A MOLECULE SIZED CHARACTER JUST STANDING THERE I CACKLED and then bro gets eaten, rice i miss you everyday XDDD fries is also the highlight for me HE'S SO BADASS in a funny way and im REALLLYYY really hoping he doesnt get out *crossing my paws* he's one of my last remaining favs in the show and i can't live in a world where nickel is still living over fries KJHKADSHJADS
but forreal BFDIA does feel a little empty without gelatin, maybe its my bias? maybe its because he debuted in BFDIA so i just associate him with the season? I JUST wasnt expecting him to get out so early like that? i miss his presence dearly ANDDDDD his dynamic with fries n firey WAS GREAT (esp fries . god . ive been getting more attached to them lately bc their dynamic is just so good but this aint about them TEEHEE) but back to the meat - this episode
IM so glad they managed to get THE mr kevin macleod on the episode too!! i guess this also just confirmed what his objectsona would be? i do wonder if he picked it out himself or if they picked for him? either way its so nice seeing THE guy that pretty much "made" the bfdi ost being apart of this project, its very sweet and i just loved his little orchestra of objects !!!!!!!!! i thought that whole bit was so nice and sweet :O] and their designs are wonderful! tophat always does a great job with his stuff
AND SPEAKING OF THE MAN HIMSELF! IM SO DAMN EXCITED FOR THAT VINYL TO RELEASE oh my GODDDDDD its such a novelty to me . ofc im buying the vinyl with kevin macleod music on it AND THE VINYL ITSELF IS SO CUTE!! i love it when they do funky stuff w the records so seeing how its literally just a bfdi sky/grass thing is so nice. and hey i got a record player for times like these! so im SUPER pumped for its release...i do wonder if it'll come with any extra goodies when ppl order em tho! idk i feel like it be cool haha
|
|